By Deborah Jeanne Sergeant
Dietary changes to manage Type 2 diabetes may seem confusing and hard to handle. Following a well-known and publicized paleo diet may seem an easier way to manage the disease.
Paleo emphasizes meat, whole fruits and vegetables and tree nuts, eschewing dairy, processed foods, sugar, juice, alcohol, caffeine and grains.
Research from City of Hope National Medical Center studied the effects of paleo diet on Type 2 diabetics. While some patients lost weight while eating paleo, some of the foods banned by the plan may cause deficiencies. Local experts agreed.
Chris Purcell, certified personal trainer, wellness coach and owner of Om Body Lifestyle in Syracuse, wrote his dissertation on paleo. He said that restricting processed foods is a good idea for people who need to lose weight.
“If you’re Type 2 diabetic, you can pay attention to foods that cause insulin spikes,” he said. “I’m a big advocate of it.”
He explained that since paleo restricts grains, that could help diabetics, who need to cut back on high glycemic index foods that cause blood sugar to spike.
He added paleo also restricts foods that, in many people, lead to inflammation, such as grains and dairy.
Other positive effects of effective dietary changes can include weight loss in about three months and improved insulin resistance.
Registered nurse Jane Giambrone, certified diabetes educator and clinical diabetes care manager for Rochester Regional Health’s Unity Diabetes and Endocrinology Services, agrees that “eliminating processed foods, refined grains and refined sugars may improve blood sugar levels.”
“That helps control blood sugar and also helps with reducing cancer and heart disease risk per Dr. Raynald Samoa, an endocrinologist and assistant professor of medicine at City of Hope,” Giambrone said.
Paleo comes with some drawbacks. Though more and more foods are labeled as “paleo-friendly” and followers can download apps to help them decide if foods fit the plan, it is highly restrictive. Many people would find this difficult to follow long-term.
The narrowness of paleo diet may make it harder to eat enough natural sources of calcium since dairy’s off the menu.
The only exception is heavy cream and butter. Animal fat is also fine. All of these contain high levels of saturated fat, which the American Heart Association associates with raised LDL cholesterol levels in the blood, increasing the risk of heart disease and stroke.
Paleo also forbids numerous foods rich in nutrients, such as cereal grains and legumes such as soy, peanuts, kidney beans, pinto beans, navy beans, split peas and black eyed peas.
For people on a budget, the paleo diet may be more difficult to follow since many of its permissible foods are expensive, such as wild-caught salmon, coconut oil, more costly pasture-raised meat, and organic foods.
“Everyone is different and what may be right for one person, may not be right for another person,” Giambrone said. “I do believe this may be an ideal option for some. With any diabetes meal plan it is important that the food plan is individualized.
“It’s best to talk with a primary care physician to see if this is a meal plan worth trying if you have diabetes.